1. Home
  2. Analysis
  3. Excedrin
  4. Amerge

Excedrin vs. Amerge: side effect and effectiveness comparison (a real world drug study)

Summary:

We compare the side effects and drug effectiveness of Excedrin and Amerge. The phase IV clinical study is created by eHealthMe based on reports (from sources including the FDA) of 26,160 people who take Excedrin and Amerge, and is updated regularly.

What is Excedrin?

Excedrin has active ingredients of acetaminophen; aspirin; caffeine. It is often used in headache. eHealthMe is studying from 22,740 Excedrin users. Check the latest studies of Excedrin.

What is Amerge?

Amerge has active ingredients of naratriptan hydrochloride. It is often used in migraine. eHealthMe is studying from 1,470 Amerge users. Check the latest studies of Amerge.

On Jul, 17, 2026

26,160 people who take Excedrin and Amerge are studied.

Excedrin vs Amerge drug comparison reports.

Drugs being compared in this study:

  • Excedrin (acetaminophen; aspirin; caffeine)
  • Amerge (naratriptan hydrochloride)

Most common side effects of the drugs, overall:

Click here to view

Most common side effects of the drugs, in long term (1+ years) use:

Click here to view

Drug effectiveness:

Excedrin:

  • not at all: 2.15 %
  • somewhat: 19.35 %
  • moderate: 33.47 %
  • high: 29.7 %
  • very high: 15.32 %

Amerge:

  • not at all: 2.17 %
  • somewhat: 8.7 %
  • moderate: 28.26 %
  • high: 50.0 %
  • very high: 10.87 %

Want to compare Excedrin with Amerge?

- Personalize this study to your gender and age (0-99+)

How to use the study?

DO NOT STOP MEDICATIONS without first consulting your doctor. If there are any serious or long term adverse effects discovered in the study, discuss the study with your doctor to ensure that proper medication management will be in place if applicable.

Related studies

Alternative drugs to, pros and cons of:

Browse all side effects of Excedrin:

a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

Browse all side effects of Amerge:

a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

How the study uses the data?

The study is based on acetaminophen; aspirin; caffeine and naratriptan hydrochloride (the active ingredients of Excedrin and Amerge, respectively). Other drugs that have the same active ingredients (e.g. generic drugs or brand names) are also considered. Dosage of drugs is not considered in the study.

Who is eHealthMe?

With medical big data and proven AI/ML algorithms, eHealthMe provides a platform for everyone to run phase IV clinical trials. We study millions of patients and 5,000 more each day. Results of our real-world drug study have been referenced on 800+ peer-reviewed medical publications, including The Lancet, Mayo Clinic Proceedings, and Nature. Our analysis results are available to researchers, health care professionals, patients (testimonials), and software developers (open API).

WARNING, DISCLAIMER, USE FOR PUBLICATION

WARNING: Please DO NOT STOP MEDICATIONS without first consulting a physician since doing so could be hazardous to your health.

DISCLAIMER: All material available on eHealthMe.com is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment provided by a qualified healthcare provider. All information is observation-only. Our phase IV clinical studies alone cannot establish cause-effect relationship. Different individuals may respond to medication in different ways. Every effort has been made to ensure that all information is accurate, up-to-date, and complete, but no guarantee is made to that effect. The use of the eHealthMe site and its content is at your own risk.

If you use this eHealthMe study on publication, please acknowledge it with a citation: study title, URL, accessed date.

Recent studies on eHealthMe:

© 2026 eHealthMe.com. All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of eHealthMe.com's terms of service and privacy policy.